Union Official’s Special Privileges: Super-Constitutional Powers That Eliminate Your Rights

Union officials enjoy legal immunities and powers that no other private organization or individual has been allowed by the U.S. Constitution, Congress, or any court. From forced dues to exemptions from violence, these special privileges and exemptions violate workers’ and others' constitutional rights and ignore standard contract law.

Explore the laws, real stories, and help develop the path to reform to give employees and employers their rights back.

????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

How Big Labor Gained Its Power

This is a brief summary of a critical historical analysis from the National Institute for Labor Relations Research. It traces how “Big Labor” (union bosses) transformed from voluntary, business-oriented organizations into a coercive political force through legislative exemptions, government-backed compulsory unionism, and judicial battles.

It contrasts AFL-CIO President Samuel Gompers’ early emphasis on voluntarism (“No lasting gain has ever come from compulsion”) with more recent union Presidents, such as Former SEIU President Andy Stern, who embraced “the persuasion of power,” which is excessively outsized by special privileges and exceptions, and extra-constitutional powers to trample employees' and employers' constitutional rights.

Big Labor’s Top Ten Special Privileges

(Adapted, in part, from the National Right to Work Committee's Research)

1. Exemption from Prosecution for Union Violence

U.S. v. Enmons (1973): The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the Hobbs Act does not cover violence, threats, or property destruction (e.g., gunfire at transformers) if tied to “legitimate” union goals like higher wages. This loophole has shielded thousands of incidents and several related deaths.

Consequences: Victims have lost their lives, been maimed, and other injuries while union officials and their cronies have been allowed to go free or serve only minimal sentences and/or fines while victims were brutalized and had their rights trampled.

2. Exemption from anti-monopoly laws
The Clayton Act (1914) protects unions from antitrust prosecution, allowing the elimination of competing unions or other worker organizations
 
Consequences: union create monopolies and force employers to hire from their pool of workers rather allowing competition for employers to find the best employees or search for competitive rates for jobs.
3. Power to Force Unwanted Union "Representation"
The NLRA (1935), FLRA (1978), and RLA (1926) imposed exclusive (monopoly) bargaining, meaning that even employees who want no part of the union must work under the union officials' rules and controls.
 
Consequences: Even in a Right to Work state, if the union has a contract they control the working conditions of all employees under that contract, even non-union members.  Union officials often abuse this privilege and keep non-union members off jobs, limit hours of work, or assign least desirable work to non-union members; among other schemes.  
4. Power to Collect Forced Union Dues
NLRA Section 8(a)(3) allows firing workers who refuse dues in non-RTW states. (Taft-Hartley Section 14(b) lets states ban this—currently protecting workers in 26 Right to Work states, and Janus Rights allow all government employees to not pay union dues or fees.) Where Section 8(a)(3) applies in the private-sector, it allows unions to demand dues payments from all employees within the scope of the union contract and to require employers to fire employees who refuse to pay dues to unwanted union officials.
 
Consequences: in states like California, Illinois, and New York for example, unions can force you to pay union fees and dues regardless of the fee or dues amounts or be fired. 
 
NIOTE: Compelled subsidies were overturned in public sector — Janus v. AFSCME (2018, argued by National Right to Work Attorney William Messenger): a 5-4 Supreme Court decision declared forced agency fees unconstitutional, compelled speech under the First Amendment. Overruled Abood (1977). Result: Millions of public employees can now say “no” without losing their jobs; unions lost hundreds of millions in revenue and hundreds of thousands of members. This sets the model for ending private-sector forced dues nationwide.
5. Unlimited, Undisclosed electioneering
Federal Election Campaign Act exemptions let unions spend forced-dues money on politics with minimal disclosure.
 
Consequences: Unions are political organizations that spend unaccounted amounts time and money on political activities. Large sums of the unreported time and money is paid by taxpayers in the form of "union release time" or "official time" costs.  
6. Empowered to Strong-Arm Employers into Negotiations
NLRA/FLRA/RLA makes refusal to bargain an “unfair labor practice” and allows for stiff penalties, and sometimes, arbitrary penalties have been applied.
 
Consequences: There is more. Union officials strong‑arm employers by using coercive leverage points built into labor law—strikes, picketing, labor‑peace agreements, political pressure, regulatory complaints, and economic disruption—plus informal intimidation tactics that exploit the union’s monopoly status. These tactics work because unions often have exclusive bargaining rights, legal protections, and political influence that employers cannot easily counter.
7. Right to Trespass on Private Property (Ignores Property Rights)
The Norris-LaGuardia Act (1932) blocks injunctions against union officials and mobs who trespass seemingly anywhere.  Union officials gain access to private property through a mix of NLRA interpretations, NLRB rulings, court decisions, and state-level carve‑outs that treat union organizers differently from all other private actors. These carve‑outs often override normal trespass law.
 
Consequences: Just to name a few examples.

Undermines basic property rights by forcing employers to allow nonemployees onto private premises, even when it disrupts operations or violates company policy.

Creates security vulnerabilities, including uncontrolled entry points, exposure to theft or vandalism, and increased risk to employees and customers.

Interrupts production and workflow, as union agents can enter work areas, pull employees aside, or interfere with supervisors during critical operations.

Increases legal exposure, including liability for injuries to union officials, expanded OSHA or NLRB investigations, and heightened risk of regulatory complaints.

Enables intimidation and pressure tactics, allowing union officials to confront managers, monitor dissenting employees, and create a hostile environment for non‑union workers. ...

8. Union Activists Keep Jobs While Refusing to Work
Union officials can call a strike and demand their jobs back afterward; in addition, replacement workers often face retaliation from union officials and thugs who have little fear of consequences for their own actions.
 
Consequences:

Disrupts operations and productivity, forcing employers to carry workers who intentionally refuse assignments, slow down work, or engage in “inside strikes” while still on payroll.

Creates a two‑tier workforce, where union activists face no consequences for refusing work while non‑union employees are disciplined — undermining fairness, morale, and managerial authority.

Weakens supervisory control, making managers appear powerless when union activists openly defy instructions, refuse assignments, or challenge workplace rules.

Triggers more grievances and legal disputes, as union activists often use refusal‑to‑work tactics to provoke conflicts, file complaints, and escalate pressure on employers. ...

9. Union-Only Cartels on Government Projects
Private-Sector Project Labor Agreements lock out non-union contractors on federal, state, and municipal government projects, thus eliminating competition and increasing project costs. Which, in turn, increases taxes and inflation, impacting everyone.
 
It incentivizes union operatives and employers to seek legislation or procurement rules that raise the costs and burdens on taxpayers rather than open bidding for the best product at the best price.
 
Downside: These government project funding schemes take money from taxpayers by force through taxes and give it only to unionized workers. This forces taxpayers, most of whom are not unionized, to subsidize union officials getting government work without any competition from non-union shops. Thus, taxpayers do not have the right to get fair, competitive bids on projects. 
10. Government Funding of Forced Unionism
Taxpayer grant, jobs programs, training programs. loan forgiveness, union pension bailouts, funnel billions annually into union coffers.
 
Consequences:

  • Erodes democratic accountability, allowing union leaders—not elected officials—to effectively control staffing, discipline, and workplace rules in public agencies.

  • Creates a government within the government, where union officials wield veto power over management decisions, reforms, and even basic operational changes.

  • Blocks merit‑based hiring and promotion, replacing performance standards with seniority rules and union favoritism, reducing overall competence in public services.

  • Makes it nearly impossible to remove poor performers, because union contracts and grievance systems shield government employees from meaningful discipline.

  • Inflates taxpayer costs, as unions negotiate higher wages, richer benefits, and costly work rules that politicians often accept to avoid conflict.

  • Encourages political patronage, since unions use dues and manpower to influence elections, then negotiate with the very officials they helped elect.

  • Reduces efficiency and responsiveness, because managers cannot reassign staff, adjust schedules, or implement reforms without union approval.

  • Creates “no‑strike but yes‑shutdown” loopholes, where unions use slowdowns, mass grievances, and coordinated absenteeism to pressure governments without calling an official strike.

  • Undermines public safety, especially in policing, corrections, transportation, and healthcare, where union rules can block discipline, training changes, or staffing reforms.

  • Prioritizes union interests over public interests, as union leaders negotiate for job protection and political influence rather than service quality or fiscal responsibility.

  • Weakens separation of powers, because union contracts can override legislative authority, budget decisions, and executive control over agencies.

  • Encourages corruption and insider dealing, since union‑only control creates closed systems with little transparency, oversight, or competition.

Real-World Examples of Union Violence Shielded by Special Privileges

U.S. v. Enmons' decision created bad law and horrific consequences for people opposed to union officials or the goons that they controlled.

Real-World Examples of Union Violence Shielded by Special Privileges

Eddie York

Non-union coal miner shot and killed while driving past United Mine Workers picketers at the Ruffner Mine, WV. No federal Hobbs Act charges due to Emmons.
Button on each: “Read Full NILRR Reporting”

UAW's Kohler Strike

Over 400 documented incidents of violence, assaults on non-strikers (including elderly workers), property destruction, and nationwide boycotts. Local authorities often failed to intervene.
Button on each: “Read Full NILRR Reporting”

DuPont Hotel Fire

Union militants set ablaze the DuPont Hotel in Puerto Rico during New Year's Eve festivities. Hundreds paid the price, many with their lives.

Button on each: “Read Full NILRR Reporting”

RMI Titanium

Union militants vandalized environmental monitoring equipment and poured oil into electrical conduits during a dispute—classic Emmons-protected tactics.

Button on each: “Read Full NILRR Reporting”

Janus v. AFSCME – Victory for Workers and Additional Implications

Janus v. AFSCME (2018): A Landmark First Amendment Victory

The Janus v. AFSCME U.S. Supreme Court victory was probably the most significant victory for Employee Freedom and rights in the past decade.  In Janus v. AFSCME, the U.S. Supreme Court held that public-sector unions cannot force non-members to pay any fees—agency or otherwise—without their affirmative consent, because forcing workers to subsidize union speech violates the First Amendment.

Implications:

• Protects over 5 million government workers, and growing (teachers, first responders, etc.).
• Triggered massive opt-outs and follow-up lawsuits by the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation to enforce it. People are still just learning about their rights to stop paying unwanted dues.  Visit: MyJanuRights.org now to stop paying your unwanted government union dues or fees.
• Unions have lost significant revenue and membership, yet some continue resistance tactics and have received taxpayer union time to subsidize their unwanted unions.
• And proof that compelled unionism and forced fees are unconstitutional, and may help pave the way for a National Right to Work Act to extend these freedoms to the private sector.

NLRBvGM-CWAvBeck-JanusvAfscme

NLRB v. GM applies to private‑sector labor law under the NLRA. It permits agency shops. Janus applies to public‑sector labor law under the First Amendment. It prohibits agency fees without consent. Together, they show a sharp divide: agency fees are "lawful" in the private sector (unless state law forbids them), but unconstitutional in the public sector.

Current Right to Work States (5/25/2026)

Taft-Hartley Section 14(b) – The Path to State-Level Freedom

Taft-Hartley Section 14(b): Allows States the Right to Ban Forced Unionism.

Enacted in 1947 as part of the Labor Management Relations Act, Section 14(b) amended the NLRA to let every state (and territory) enact Right to Work laws. These laws prohibit unions from requiring membership or dues/fees as a condition of employment—overriding the NLRA’s original allowance of union shops.

Today (2026): 26 states have Right to Work protections, giving workers the freedom to choose. Studies consistently show that Right to Work states enjoy higher job growth, higher wages adjusted for the cost of living, and greater economic opportunity. Expanding 14(b) nationwide would end forced dues everywhere.

AFSCME Local 1746 Officers Charged in $350,000 Embezzlement; Secretary-Treasurer Pleads Guilty

AFSCME Local 1746 Officers Charged in $350,000 Embezzlement; Secretary-Treasurer Pleads Guilty

What the Department of Labor and Court Records Allege Federal investigators say two former officers of an Ohio public-employee union...
NALC Union Boss Samantha Zirkle Pleads Guilty to Felony Level Theft

NALC Union Boss Samantha Zirkle Pleads Guilty to Felony Level Theft

NALC Treasurer Samantha Zirkle pleaded guilty to a level 5 felony theft. For the crime, valued at $50,000 or more,...
APWU Union Bigwig LaTanya Gadson Pleads Guilty to Crimes

APWU Union Bigwig LaTanya Gadson Pleads Guilty to Crimes

APWU President LaTanya Gadson pleaded guilty to willful falsification of union records. She was sentenced to five years of probation...
AFSCME Union President Shukimba Carlis Pleads Guilty to Crime

AFSCME Union President Shukimba Carlis Pleads Guilty to Crime

AFSCME Local 2620 President Shukimba Carlis was investigated for wire fraud and pleaded guilty. This is just one more guilty...
AFSCME Union Boss Sofia Hererra Admits to Crime

AFSCME Union Boss Sofia Hererra Admits to Crime

AFSCME Local 2620 Treasurer Sofia Hererra took no time at all to plead guilty to wire fraud charges. From Department...
AFGE President Demetrius Baldwin Hears Criminal Sentencing

AFGE President Demetrius Baldwin Hears Criminal Sentencing

After pleading guilty to wire fraud in September, 2025, AFGE President Demetrius Baldwin has been sentenced to five years of...
Tennessee Staff Union Boss Mary F. Poindexter Sent to Prison

Tennessee Staff Union Boss Mary F. Poindexter Sent to Prison

Mary F. Poindexter, Treasurer of the Tennessee Staff Union, was sentenced to eight years in prison after admitting to theft...
AFGE President Terry Lendo Makes Guilty Plea

AFGE President Terry Lendo Makes Guilty Plea

Terry Lendo, President of AFGE Local 1745, has pleaded guilty to making false statements. He is just one more example...
IBEW Union Bigwig James Burke Pleads Guilty to Embezzling Union Funds

IBEW Union Bigwig James Burke Pleads Guilty to Embezzling Union Funds

Union bosses simply cannot be trusted with the hard-earned money of workers. James Burke, Financial Secretary of IBEW Local 549,...
APWU Union President LaTanya Gadson Pleads Guilty to Crimes

APWU Union President LaTanya Gadson Pleads Guilty to Crimes

APWU union President LaTanya Gadson has pleaded guilty to one count of willful falsification of union records. You can read...
Steelworkers President Ricky Mattison Faces Criminal Sentencing

Steelworkers President Ricky Mattison Faces Criminal Sentencing

Ricky Mattison, President of United Steelworkers Local 970, has been sentenced to five years of probation after pleading guilty to...
Another Boilermakers Union Scandal – $20 million racketeering scheme

Another Boilermakers Union Scandal – $20 million racketeering scheme

When Workers’ Hard-Earned Dues Fund Luxury and Lies, No One Should Be Forced to Pay Your Sweat Funds Their Paris...
NALC Union Boss Marcus Miller Better Get Used to a Prison Cell

NALC Union Boss Marcus Miller Better Get Used to a Prison Cell

NALC Vice President Marcus Miller has been sentenced to over a year in prison after pleading guilty to embezzling from...
NALC President Michelle Simmons Put on Probation After Guilty Plea

NALC President Michelle Simmons Put on Probation After Guilty Plea

Michelle Simmons, President of NALC Branch 390, has been sentenced to a total of five years of probation. She must...
Steelworkers President Robert Cirilo Sent to Prison

Steelworkers President Robert Cirilo Sent to Prison

United Steelworkers Local 13-1647 President Robert Cirilo has been sentenced to 21 months in prison, followed by three years of...
IUE-CWA Union Bigwig Joe Scott Pleads Guilty to Embezzlement

IUE-CWA Union Bigwig Joe Scott Pleads Guilty to Embezzlement

What an absolute shame - IUE-CWA Local 81154 Treasurer Joe Scott has admitted to embezzling from union funds. That's the...
IBEW’s James Scotti Sentenced After Guilty Pleas

IBEW’s James Scotti Sentenced After Guilty Pleas

IBEW Local 26 employee James Scotti has been sentenced to six months of home confinement after pleading guilty to conspiracy...
IBEW Union Boss James Burke Faces Embezzlement Charges

IBEW Union Boss James Burke Faces Embezzlement Charges

James Burke, Financial Secretary of IBEW Local 549, is suspected of having embezzled union funds. Some people just can't be...
Mail Handlers Union Boss Max Jaramillo Faces Multiple Criminal Charges

Mail Handlers Union Boss Max Jaramillo Faces Multiple Criminal Charges

Mail Handlers Local 331 Treasurer Max Jaramillo is facing multiple criminal charges: two counts of wire fraud and three counts...
APWU President LaTanya Gadson Faces Serious Embezzlement Charges

APWU President LaTanya Gadson Faces Serious Embezzlement Charges

LaTanya Gadson, President of APWU Local 795, may have embezzled over $11,474 from union funds and now faces charges accordingly....